David’s posterous

« Back to blog

3 Fundamental Problems with Ubuntu

I love the Ubuntu Linux operating system. I love the philosophy behind it, the community that sustains it, and the way most things work so beautifully out of the box. I am an Ubuntu convert, and would never consider going back to Windows.

However, there are three fundamental problems with Ubuntu that make me reluctant to recommend it to friends. These problems are central to the everyday user experience of almost all computer users, and until they are solved, I can't see Ubuntu entering the mainstream.

I'm aware that the blame for these problems usually lies with hardware manufacturers rather than Ubuntu developers. Nonetheless, I think Ubuntu developers should engage in serious and sustained dialogue with manufactures about resolving these issues.

The problems are these:

1. Printing. I have an Epson printer. With much ado and fuss, it will print documents from Ubuntu. However, whenever it is used in Ubuntu, the ink will run out after 10-20 pages. So not only is printing in Ubuntu a hassle that usually involves restarting the printer multiple times, it's also very expensive. When I need to replace ink, there is no utility in Ubuntu to tell me which colour ink cartridge has run out and needs replacing. So I have to load up Windows to find out.

2. Wi-fi and Stand-by mode. After Ubuntu goes into standby or hibernation, it will not connect to Wi-Fi. I understand that this is a common problem with Linux, and not unique to Ubuntu distributions. This is extremely frustrating, and means I waste a lot of energy because when I leave my computer for an hour, I can only turn off the display. Everything else must be left running, or I will have to restart my computer when I return to it, losing everything that I'm working on.

I see this as the biggest problem facing Linux today. Computers are responsible for as many emissions as airplanes. Ubuntu has an ethical stance, and should be taking the lead on reducing emissions. Until Linux puts together a viable standby mode that does not disable WiFi, I will remain highly reluctant to recommend it to anyone.

3. Display. This is a smaller issue, but still a key problem. My computer is less than one year old, yet its graphics card is incompatible with Ubuntu. Even with the hardware drivers installed, I can't get visual effects to work. Installing the graphics card driver actually slows down and ruins the basic graphics rather than helping. Although this is less fundamental than standby mode, as it's still possible to use a computer without visual effects, it's disappointing only to have a basic experience on advanced hardware.

What are your thoughts and experiences of using Ubuntu and other Linux distributions?

Comments (0)

Leave a comment...

 
To leave a comment on this posterous, please login by clicking one of the following.
Posterous-login     Connect     twitter